Melatonin vs Magnesium: The Honest Sleep Comparison You Need!

Sleepless woman suffering from insomnia, sleep apnea or stress. Tired and exhausted lady. Headache or migraine. Awake in the middle of the night. Frustrated person with problem. Alarm clock with time.

Last Updated on November 27, 2022 by theworldofsleepstaff

Melatonin and magnesium are popular supplements to improve sleep and reduce stress. Both are natural food substances and are available as dietary supplements, but which is better?

Right here we finally answer that question, although it depends completely on your own situation.

For example if your sleep issues are caused by stress magnesium may be the better choice for you – as we’ll explain later. But if you’re struggling to sleep due to jet lag or shift work then melatonin would be the better choice.

Below we’ll look at how these two supplements compare regarding their effectiveness, side effects and other key factors, all so you can make an informed decision about which one is right for you.

Please note: This content was only written as a reference, using third-party background information. It is not medical advice, so please consult your healthcare provider for personalized guidance.

CONTENTS:

  1. Which Is Better For Sleep?
  2. Five Important Similarities
  3. Six Important Differences
  4. Can I Take Magnesium & Melatonin Together
  5. How The Side Effects Differ From Each Other
  6. Frequently Asked Questions
Woman sleeping in her bed at night, she is lying on her stomach
iStock.com/cyano66

Melatonin vs Magnesium: which one is better for sleep?

That is the million-dollar question, and it all depends on your individual needs. Both melatonin and magnesium can be beneficial for sleep in different ways.

Firstly, you need to know what each of these nutrients does.

Melatonin is a hormone that regulates our circadian rhythm, also known as our sleep-wake cycle. It helps to regulate the timing of your sleep and wake times, making it easier to fall asleep and stay asleep through the night.

On the other hand magnesium is an essential mineral that improves relaxation and reduces stress levels, leading to better sleep quality.

The most apparent difference between melatonin and magnesium is that melatonin is a hormone, while magnesium is an essential mineral. As a result, melatonin has been studied extensively for its ability to help induce sleep, and is backed by science as an effective sleep aid.

At the same time, there needs to be more evidence of the effects of taking magnesium as a supplement specifically for sleep. However, some studies have shown that taking additional magnesium can help reduce stress and improve relaxation in the body, resulting in better sleep.

curly haired woman sleeping in bed. healthy sleep concept. dice composed in melatonin word. and glass of water on bedside table. melatonin and circadian rhythms.
iStock.com/Yulia Panova

Magnesium vs Melatonin: Five Important Similarities

If you’re having trouble sleeping, you might be looking for a solution that doesn’t involve any medications. Magnesium and melatonin are two natural sleep aids that can help you get the restful sleep your body needs without taking a pill every night.

But how are these two supplements similar and different? First, we’ll explore their similarities…

1. They Help Improve Sleep Quality

Both magnesium and melatonin are said to help improve the quality of your sleep by helping you fall asleep faster, stay asleep longer and wake up feeling more refreshed.

Magnesium helps relax tense muscles, while melatonin is a hormone naturally produced in the body that helps regulate our sleep patterns.

A young brunette woman sleeping in white bed,
iStock.com/puhimec

2. They Are Both Natural Supplements

Both magnesium and melatonin are natural supplements found in food sources or taken as supplements.

Magnesium, for example, is found naturally in foods like green leafy vegetables, nuts and seeds. Melatonin is produced by the body during the night and can also be supplemented with pills or liquids.

3. They May Help Reduce Stress & Anxiety

Studies have shown magnesium and melatonin can help reduce stress and anxiety levels. Magnesium helps relax tense muscles, while melatonin benefits those with insomnia or other sleep-related problems. It’s important to note that these supplements should not be used in place of medical advice.

Magnesium and melatonin have many similarities in helping you get quality sleep. They work naturally with the body’s systems to improve sleep quality, reduce stress and anxiety, and are found naturally in foods.

But which supplement is best for you? Keep reading as soon we’ll show you the important differences between magnesium and melatonin.

Sleepless woman suffering from insomnia, sleep apnea or stress. Tired and exhausted lady. Headache or migraine. Awake in the middle of the night. Frustrated person with problem. Alarm clock with time.
iStock.com/Tero Vesalainen

4. They May Help With Jetlag

Jet lag is a common problem for travellers, but magnesium and melatonin may help.

Magnesium helps relax tense muscles that can be tight from sitting in an aeroplane for hours, while melatonin has been found to help regulate the body’s internal clock and ease symptoms of jet lag.

However, it’s important to note that neither of these supplements should be used as a substitute for medical advice. Instead, talk to your healthcare provider if you have questions about which supplement is best for you and how to use it safely.

5. They May Help Reduce Depression

Studies have found that magnesium and melatonin may help reduce symptoms of depression. Magnesium helps relax tense muscles that can be tight from the stress of depression, while melatonin helps regulate your sleep cycle, which is often disrupted in those with depression.

These two supplements are similar in that they can help you get a quality night’s sleep and potentially reduce stress, anxiety, and depression. In addition, both are natural supplements found in food sources or as pill supplements.

Man sitting on bed at night looking stressed
iStock.com/tommaso79

Magnesium Vs Melatonin: Six Important Differences

Understanding the differences between magnesium and melatonin is essential before deciding which one is best for you. Here are some of the key differences between these two natural sleep aids

1. Magnesium Takes Longer To Take Effect

Magnesium takes longer to take effect than melatonin, usually about 30 minutes after ingestion. This means magnesium is best taken in the early evening before you go to bed, while melatonin should be taken shortly before sleep.

Or take both simultaneously, as magnesium can help your body better absorb the melatonin you’re taking.

MG text. Symbol of magnesium on plate
iStock.com/golibtolibov

2. Magnesium Has More Side Effects Than Melatonin

Magnesium has been known to have side effects such as nausea or diarrhoea when taken in large doses. This is because magnesium is a mineral and can interfere with other medications you may be taking.

Melatonin, on the other hand, has fewer side effects than magnesium. In addition, it’s been found safe for short-term use, with few reported side effects such as headaches or irritability.

3. Melatonin Is Better For Jet Lag

Melatonin is also better than magnesium when it comes to treating jet lag. Studies have shown that taking melatonin can help reset your body’s internal clock and reduce the effects of jet lag.

Because jet lag is caused by our body’s natural rhythms being disrupted, taking melatonin can help reset those rhythms and make it easier to adjust to a new time zone. Magnesium may also help but is not as effective in treating jet lag as melatonin.

Tired man lying on the bed jet lag
iStock.com/bernardbodo

4. Magnesium Has A Wider Range Of Benefits Than Melatonin

Magnesium has a broader range of benefits than melatonin.

In addition to helping improve sleep quality, magnesium can also help reduce muscle cramps, headaches and joint pain. It’s also been found to help reduce anxiety levels.

On the other hand, melatonin is mainly used to improve sleep quality and treat jet lag. While it may have some other benefits, magnesium is more well-documented.

5. Natural Source Differences

The natural sources of magnesium and melatonin also differ. Magnesium is found naturally in foods like green leafy vegetables, nuts and seeds. On the other hand, melatonin is produced by the body during the night and can also be supplemented with pills or liquids.

Other melatonin sources include tart cherries, walnuts, and sunflower seeds, while magnesium is found in foods like oatmeal, legumes and avocados.

young guy is smiling while eating porridge with berries in kitchen at home
iStock.com/GeorgeRudy

6. Melatonin Is The Better Option For Shift Work

Melatonin supplements are better suited to those suffering from jet lag or shift work symptoms, as they are more effective in resetting the body’s clock. Magnesium supplements, on the other hand, may only help with general sleep disturbances such as difficulty.

So while both supplements can help you get a better night’s sleep, magnesium may be best taken in the early evening, and melatonin should be taken shortly before bedtime. Magnesium also has more side effects than melatonin, so it’s important to talk to your doctor before taking any supplements.

Both magnesium and melatonin are natural sleep aids that can help you get a better night’s sleep. But it is essential to understand the differences between these two supplements and talk to your doctor before taking either.

Also, remember that the best supplement for you will depend on your unique needs, so consult your healthcare provider before beginning any new supplement routine.

White bottle and pills, letters Melatonin, alarm clock and sleep mask on light grey background. Sleeping backdrop Concept melatonin, insomnia and good night.
iStock.com/MurzikNata

Should I Take Magnesium And Melatonin Together?

Though magnesium and melatonin have been proven to help improve sleep, taking them together is not generally recommended. The combination of the two needs to be studied more, so the potential side effects or interactions are unknown. It’s best to speak with your doctor before taking any supplements.

That being said, magnesium and melatonin are both natural supplements that work to improve sleep quality in different ways. Magnesium works to relax the body’s muscles and can help reduce stress, while melatonin is a hormone produced by the pineal gland that helps regulate your internal body clock.

Though their effects are related, taking them together could increase the risk of side effects. Some potential side effects of taking magnesium and melatonin together include headaches, nausea, dizziness, increased anxiety, and changes in hormone levels. Additionally, there is a potential risk of overdose if taken in too high doses.

The best way to decide if taking magnesium and melatonin together is right for you is to speak to your doctor. They can recommend the best dosage for you and help you decide whether or not it’s a good idea for your situation.

woman sleeping on her side
iStock.com/gorodenkoff

How The Side Effects Differ From Each Other

Overall, melatonin and magnesium have similarities and differences regarding their effects on sleep. While both are generally safe, one must remember that side effects can occur with either supplement.

Therefore, it’s always best to talk to your doctor before taking anything for sleep, especially if you have any underlying medical conditions or take any other medications.

Ultimately, the best way to improve your sleep is to make healthy lifestyle changes, such as avoiding screens before bedtime and sticking to a regular sleep schedule. You should get better rest and enjoy a more fulfilling night’s sleep by taking the proper steps.

When it comes to side effects, both melatonin and magnesium are generally safe when taken as directed. But let us compare the most common side effects for each in detail.

Man sleeping on side in bed
iStock.com/gorodenkoff

Magnesium: Side Effects

The side effects of magnesium on sleep are:

1. It can lead to an upset stomach – While magnesium is generally safe and well-tolerated, it may cause some people to experience an upset stomach or nausea.

In addition, it’s important to remember that magnesium can interfere with certain medications, so talk to a doctor before taking it as a sleep aid if you are on any other medication.

2. It can reduce sleep quality – Magnesium has been found to promote more profound and prolonged sleep. However, some studies have suggested that it may be less beneficial for quality.

For example, one study showed magnesium supplementation resulted in less restorative sleep than a placebo.

3. It can cause headaches – Magnesium is a muscle relaxant which can help reduce tension and improve sleep quality.

However, it may also cause headaches in some individuals. Talk to a doctor if you experience persistent headaches after taking magnesium as a sleep aid.

Woman with headache
iStock.com/Khunatorn

Melatonin: Side Effects

Melatonin is another popular option for people struggling with sleep issues, but the side effects of this supplement are slightly different.

The side effects of melatonin on sleep are:

1. It can cause drowsiness – Although it is generally safe and well-tolerated, some people experience drowsiness after taking melatonin as a sleep aid.

This can be especially true if taken too close to bedtime or in higher doses than recommended.

2. It can disrupt the natural sleep-wake cycle – Melatonin is designed to help regulate your body’s natural sleep-wake cycle. However, some people find that it has the opposite effect and disrupts their circadian rhythm when taken regularly for long periods

iStock.com/shironosov

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How long do you need to take melatonin or magnesium to improve sleep?

A: It depends on the individual’s needs and preferences. Some people may find relief after just a few days, while others may need to take it for a more extended period. It’s always best to talk to a doctor before beginning any supplement routine

Q: What other steps can I take to improve sleep besides supplements?

A: You can do many things to get better rest, such as avoiding screens before bedtime and having a regular sleep schedule.

Exercising regularly and managing stress levels can also help improve sleep quality. Finally, ensure enough natural sunlight during the day, which helps keep your circadian rhythm in check.

Sleeping woman in bed at night in dark bedroom.
iStock.com/Tero Vesalainen

Magnesium vs Melatonin: Which Is Better?

Overall, melatonin and magnesium can benefit sleep in different ways. And depending on your individual needs, one works better than the other.

If your sleep issues are caused by stress maybe magnesium would be the better choice for you, but if you’re struggling to sleep due to jet lag or shift work then melatonin would be the better choice.

If you’re having difficulty sleeping, it’s best to consult your doctor before taking any supplements to ensure it is safe.