Chamomile vs Peppermint Tea: An Honest Comparison For Sleep, Side Effects & More!

cups of tea with mint on wooden

Last Updated on December 18, 2022 by theworldofsleepstaff

Regarding natural remedies for sleep and relaxation, chamomile and peppermint are two of the most popular herbal teas. No wonder too, as both teas have long histories of use as calming and soothing beverages that can help induce a good night’s rest. But which one is the best choice for you?

Both herbs have compounds that can help reduce stress and anxiety and can be enjoyed either hot or cold. But the sedative effects of chamomile tea could make it a better choice if you have sleep issues like insomnia, while the relaxing properties of peppermint tea may be better if you are struggling to relax at night.

However that’s just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to how these two are different and similar.

That’s why below we will compare chamomile vs peppermint tea to see which could be better for you, and discuss the potential side effects of these two as well.

CONTENTS:

  1. Which Is Better For Sleep?
  2. The Similarities
  3. The Differences
  4. Can I Take Peppermint & Chamomile Together
  5. How The Side Effects Compare
  6. FAQs
  7. Is Chamomile And Other Mint Tea Good For Sleep?
Girl drinks tea from a mug in bed wrapped in a blanket. She is enjoying or she is not sleeping or sick.
iStock.com/franz12

Chamomile vs Peppermint Tea: which is better for sleep?

When it comes to helping with sleep, both chamomile and peppermint tea can be beneficial. Although one may work better for you than the other due to their unique properties.

Chamomile tea is known for its calming effects that help people relax and drift off to sleep. It also contains compounds like apigenin, which may have mild sedative properties.

Peppermint tea, on the other hand, has menthol, which has been shown to reduce anxiety and stress. This can help people fall asleep more quickly.

Ultimately, what tea is best for sleep depends on the individual’s preferences and needs.

For example, chamomile tea may be better if you need a more substantial sedative effect. However, peppermint tea may be better if you want to relax and unwind before bedtime.

Ultimately, it’s essential to experiment with different teas and find out what works best for you. Regardless of which tea you choose, a cup of hot tea can be the perfect way to wind down after a long day and enjoy a restful night’s sleep.

iStock.com/Sonja Rachbauer

Chamomile vs Peppermint Tea For Sleep: The Similarities

1. Both Teas Contain Compounds That Can Help You Relax

These two teas contain compounds that can help to relax and soothe the body, making them both beneficial in aiding sleep.

The active compounds in chamomile tea are apigenin and luteolin, while peppermint tea contains menthol, limonene, and menthone.

What makes the components effective is that when combined, they can help to reduce stress and anxiety. This benefits those who struggle with sleep due to underlying mental health issues or general stress.

Man sleeping on side in bed
iStock.com/gorodenkoff

2. Both Teas Are Non-Caffeinated

Since caffeine can disrupt quality sleep, later in the day you must consume beverages without this stimulant to get a good night’s rest. Chamomile and peppermint tea are naturally caffeine-free, making them ideal for promoting sleep.

These two teas are also widely available, so you can easily purchase them from your local grocery store or online.

Image via Unsplash+

3. Both Teas Are Affordable

The cost of herbal teas can vary significantly, but chamomile and peppermint tea are both generally quite affordable. This is excellent news for those who may not have the budget to buy more expensive teas but still want to enjoy these benefits.

For those on a budget, chamomile and peppermint tea are great options for getting quality rest without breaking the bank.

Man harvesting chamomile flower heads on the meadow.
iStock.com/Nataliia Yankovets

4. Both Can Be Consumed Hot Or Cold

Chamomile and peppermint tea can be enjoyed either hot or cold, depending on your preference. This gives you the flexibility to enjoy your preferred beverage at any time of day.

Cold brews are especially popular on hot summer days, while a warm cup of chamomile or peppermint tea is perfect for those cosy winter evenings.

Overall, chamomile and peppermint tea have much in common regarding promoting quality sleep. Both herbal teas are naturally caffeine-free, contain compounds that can help reduce stress and anxiety, and are both widely available and affordable.

Plus, you can enjoy them either hot or cold, so you can have a cup of tea whenever it’s convenient. With all these similarities, it’s no wonder why many people turn to chamomile and peppermint tea for better sleep.

cups of tea with mint on wooden
iStock.com/Maya23k

Chamomile vs Peppermint Tea For Sleep: The Differences

While there are several similarities between chamomile and peppermint tea, they also have some essential differences that can make one better suited for promoting sleep than the other.

1. Chamomile Tea Has Soothing Effects

Chamomile tea contains apigenin, a compound that may have mild sedative effects. This makes it ideal for those who have insomnia or need help getting to sleep quickly.

The only downside is that the sedative effects of chamomile tea may be too intense for some people. Avoiding this type of tea may be best before bedtime if you’re sensitive to the effects of herbs and medications.

Young woman sleeping on the couch at home, she is wearing wireless headphones and listening to music
iStock.com/cyano66

2. Peppermint Tea Can Help With Digestion

Peppermint tea contains menthol, which can help to relax the muscles in your gut and improve digestion. This makes it an excellent choice for those who suffer from digestive problems, such as gas, bloating, or indigestion.

Plus, improved digestion may also help you get better quality sleep since your body won’t be working to keep up with digestion while trying to rest.

iStock.com/Prostock-Studio

3. The Taste Of Chamomile & Peppermint Tea Can Vary

The flavour of both teas can range from very mild to quite substantial, depending on the type. While many people enjoy the subtle taste of chamomile tea, others may prefer the minty flavour of peppermint tea.

Regarding which tastes better, this is a matter of personal preference and can vary significantly from person to person.

4. The Effects Of Chamomile & Peppermint Tea Can Differ

Although both teas are used for promoting sleep, their effects on the body may be slightly different.

For instance, some people find that drinking chamomile tea helps them feel relaxed and sleepy before bedtime, while others find they get energy from drinking peppermint tea.

Ultimately, it’s essential to experiment with both teas to see which works best for you.

Woman with coffee or tea reclining in bed
iStock.com/gpointstudio

Should I take Chamomile And Peppermint Tea Together?

The answer to this question would depend on your individual needs and preferences. There is no definitive answer as it can vary from person to person.

If you want a soothing effect, then chamomile tea alone could be better than taking both together. However, combining chamomile and peppermint tea could be beneficial if you want an energising effect.

Ultimately, it is best to consult your doctor before taking any herbal teas, especially if you are pregnant or breastfeeding. Exercise caution when mixing different herbs is also recommended, as some interactions can be dangerous. Research before mixing teas and finding an optimal combination that works for you is always a good idea.

To conclude, if you are considering taking chamomile and peppermint tea together, it is best to consult your doctor first. Additionally, before combining them into a single beverage, please familiarise yourself with any potential interactions between the two herbs. Doing this ensures your tea-drinking experience is as safe and enjoyable as possible!

Man harvesting chamomile flower heads on the meadow.
iStock.com/Nataliia Yankovets

How Do The Side Effects Compare?

Chamomile Tea

One of the most popular herbal teas, chamomile tea has many health benefits. However, some people may experience an allergic reaction to it or experience side effects such as dizziness or vomiting.

In rare cases, heavy consumption can cause drowsiness, confusion or even a drop in blood pressure.

Peppermint Tea

Peppermint tea, while touted for its health benefits, can sometimes cause side effects such as heartburn or flushing. It may also worsen gallbladder issues in some people.

Sick female with allergies
iStock.com/MonstArrr

FAQs

How long does it take for chamomile tea to make you sleepy?

It can take 15-20 minutes for chamomile tea to start making you feel sleepy.

Does chamomile make you groggy the next day?

No, chamomile tea does not make you groggy the next day. Instead, it can help promote better sleep quality so that you wake up refreshed and energised.

How often should I drink peppermint tea?

Drinking peppermint tea no more than twice a day is generally recommended.

Sleeping woman in bed at night in dark bedroom.
iStock.com/Tero Vesalainen

Is Chamomile And Other Mint Tea Good For Sleep?

Chamomile and mint tea are both known for their calming properties and have been used traditionally as a natural remedy to help promote restful sleep.

Chamomile has been shown in some studies to reduce anxiety and improve sleep quality, while mint is thought to help relax the muscles and ease tension. Combining these two herbs may be a good choice for those looking to improve their sleep quality.

However, it must be noted that individual responses to herbs can vary greatly. Consult your doctor or healthcare provider before adding any herbal remedy to your routine. Other lifestyle changes such as reducing stress, exercising regularly, and establishing regular sleep routines are also essential.

iStock.com/Liudmyla Yaremenko

Chamomile vs Peppermint Tea: Final Thoughts

Chamomile and peppermint tea are popular options for improving sleep quality. Both herbs have compounds that can help reduce stress and anxiety and can be enjoyed either hot or cold.

The key differences between the two teas are their sedative effects, flavour profile, and how they affect the body. Ultimately, it’s essential to experiment with both teas to determine which works best for you. However, either chamomile tea or peppermint tea can be beneficial for promoting quality sleep.

No matter which type of tea you choose, adding a cup of herbal tea to your nightly routine may be the key to getting a better night’s rest. Give it a try and see if chamomile or peppermint tea can help you get the quality sleep you need. Good luck!